How much of what we do is truly “genuine” rather than simple emulation or opposition? In the beginning, everything we do is emulation. Our control of our bodies’ movement is based in our re-creation of what we have seen and been encouraged to do. Babies ignored do not learn how to move independently, instead they remain fairly motionless, although they may see movement happening around them in order to meet their minimum survival needs.
So everything we do is built on a foundation of learning by doing, but doing alone is insufficient, we need reinforcement to know if we accomplished our goal, and the goal itself can be complicated too. Once we master, or at least become proficient with our bodies, we move on to more complex “doing”. Decisions concerning what we say and participate in become extensions of what we do with our bodies.
Well past infancy we still learn by emulation to gain life skills that we desire to use. Decision making skills develop as we use our life skills to accomplish goals. Decision making is also learned through emulation, initially. As such, many of us get to an emotional place where every decision we make is solely in emulation of or opposition to outside forces; rather than being generated from our own goals.
This focus on external stimuli generally stems from expectations that we have regarding our relationships with others. Feeling resentful of or obligated to others is often wrapped up in feeling not-in-control and wanting to either please or retaliate against forces we feel we can’t subdue. Emulating or opposing can also be a sign of low self confidence, which tends to lie near lack of control issues as well. Sometimes it’s lack of motivation or lack of education that prevent wise decision making too, but it’s not entirely those folks’ fault when they’re unable or unwilling to make healthy choices.
Independent decision making based on critical thinking in consideration of our limitations and long term goals should be the process we all use to determine our actions. We should be deciding what we do based on criteria that we have determined through analysis of their relevance and benefit to our wellbeing and aspirations. Those criteria should hold some similarities between folks, like basic self care, etc. But many criteria will be suited to the individual, depending on their developmental needs and their plans for the future, as well as their desires.
It can be difficult to separate our own issues and aspirations from those who have had the most influence in our lives, as deference to their preferences shows them our commitment to relations with them. But anyone who is confident enough in their own abilities and life goals would not need others to follow them blindly or copy them at every turn. Surely imitation is the highest form of flattery, but it is not the highest form of self actualization, nor accomplishment.
As for opposition, from the Queen of Contrary let me say, it doesn’t hurt them, and it just keeps you from living your best life. Plus, they don’t need all that effort and attention – pay that to yourself and you’ll be doubly rewarded.